Ideas to shop around
Directions rather than one particular thing, for when you’d rather choose. Some come with a few that fit.

Craft and jewelry kits
Clay, mosaic and bracelet kits let a tween make something to keep. Mosaic frames take longer, bracelet kits finish fast.
3 that fit · about $14.99 – $24.99
Make Your Own Clay Jewelry Bowls Kitabout $24.99 · amazon.com
DIY Mosaic Photo Frame Craft Kitabout $14.99 · amazon.com
Friendship Bracelet Making Kitabout $15.99 · amazon.com

LEGO sets
Creator 3 in 1 sets can be rebuilt three ways, Technic is for harder builds, and the Speed Champions Bugatti is a quick car build. The two Bugatti listings are near twins.
5 that fit · about $15.99 – $23.99
LEGO Creator 3 in 1 Retro Gaming Consoleabout $15.99 · amazon.com
LEGO Technic Bush Planeabout $22.49 · amazon.com
LEGO Speed Champions Bugatti Vision GTabout $22.35 · amazon.com
LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Retro Roller Skateabout $23.99 · amazon.com
LEGO Speed Champions Bugatti Vision Gran Turismoabout $22.35 · amazon.com

Slime kits
Elmer's kits are the cheap, well known option, and the galaxy kit is more visual with glitter and glow effects.
4 that fit · about $11.92 – $28.64
UIVIEHIR Slime Kitabout $11.92 · amazon.com
Original Stationery Galaxy Slime Kitabout $24.99 · amazon.com
Elmer's Color Rush Slime Kitabout $28.64 · amazon.com
Elmer's Celebration Slime Kitabout $23.06 · amazon.com

Card and board games
Herd Mentality and Hedbanz work for a group, Goat Cheese Pizza is a quick card game, and UNO Flip and Liar's UNO add twists to a game most families already know.
5 that fit · about $9.95 – $24.99
Herd Mentality Board Gameabout $24.99 · amazon.com
Hedbanz Picture Guessing Gameabout $15.39 · amazon.com
Goat Cheese Pizza Card Gameabout $9.95 · amazon.com
Mattel UNO FLIP! Card Gameabout $11.99 · amazon.com
Mattel Liar's UNO Card Gameabout $11.78 · amazon.com

Diaries and journals
Diaries with locks give a tween a private place to write, and a DIY journal kit adds a craft step first.
4 that fit · about $8.49 – $21.98
Axolotl Diary with Lock and Keysabout $8.49 · amazon.com
Secret Diary with Lock for Girls Ages 8 to 12about $21.98 · amazon.com
Nollh DIY Journal Kitabout $17.98 · amazon.com
CAGIE Diary with Lockabout $15.27 · amazon.com

Jigsaw puzzles
A 300 piece puzzle is a good first size for tweens, easier than a 1000 piece one.
One that fits · about $17.39
Ravensburger Happy Animal Buddies 300 Piece Puzzleabout $17.39 · amazon.com

Outdoor and active play
Nerf Elite 2.0 blasters for backyard play and a multisport helmet for bikes and skates.
3 that fit · about $10.88 – $24.99
Nerf Elite 2.0 Commander RD-6 Blasterabout $10.88 · amazon.com
Nerf Elite 2.0 Trailblazer RD-8 Blasterabout $17.99 · amazon.com
80SIX Multisport Helmet for Kidsabout $24.99 · amazon.com

Cozy gifts
A glow in the dark sports blanket for movie nights.
One that fits · about $14.39
Glow Sports Blanket for Boysabout $14.39 · amazon.com