Ideas to shop around
Directions rather than one particular thing, for when you’d rather choose. Some come with a few that fit.

Puzzles
Chunky wooden and cardboard puzzles with few pieces. Melissa and Doug chunky puzzles are easiest to grip, and Ravensburger My First puzzles step up a little with bigger scenes.
4 that fit · about $9.09 – $17.45
Melissa and Doug Farm Animals Chunky Puzzleabout $9.09 · amazon.com
Wooden Peg Puzzles for Toddlersabout $9.37 · amazon.com
Ravensburger My First Puzzles: What's the Weather?about $17.45 · amazon.com
Ravensburger My First Puzzle: On the Farmabout $12.95 · amazon.com

Learning Toys for Toddlers
Toys that teach by doing. The VTech toolbox makes noise and teaches counting, while the magnetic fishing game builds hand eye skills without batteries.
3 that fit · about $8.99 – $20.99
VTech Drill and Learn Toolboxabout $20.99 · amazon.com
Montessori Learning Toyabout $8.99 · amazon.com
Magnetic Wooden Fishing Gameabout $9.99 · amazon.com

Crayons and finger paint
Large crayons are easier for small hands than standard ones, silky twist crayons do not break, and washable finger paint is the lowest mess way to start.
3 that fit · about $5.11 – $17.31
Crayola Large Crayons, 8 Countabout $5.11 · amazon.com
JUPITEARTH Silky Twist Crayonsabout $13.29 · amazon.com
Crayola Washable Finger Paints, 6 Countabout $17.31 · amazon.com

Play kitchen and pretend play
A play kitchen and a farm set for pretend play. The kitchen takes the most space, and the Little People farm is a smaller gift that suits a toddler who likes animals.
2 that fit · about $35.99 – $38.06
Dramation Kids Kitchen Playsetabout $35.99 · amazon.com
Fisher-Price Little People Caring for Animals Farmabout $38.06 · amazon.com

Stacking and sorting toys
Shape sorters, stackers and building bags. Hape and Melissa and Doug are sturdier wood picks, while Mega Bloks and Sassy are lighter and easier to carry.
5 that fit · about $9.97 – $24.99
Mega Bloks First Builders Big Building Bagabout $14.97 · amazon.com
Hape Wooden Wonder Shape Sorterabout $24.99 · amazon.com
M&D Match and Roll Shape Sorterabout $18.89 · amazon.com
Melissa & Doug Rainbow Stackerabout $9.97 · amazon.com
Sassy Stacks of Circles Stacking Ringabout $9.99 · amazon.com

Wooden vehicles
Wooden cars and town vehicles for push and roll play. Wood lasts longer than plastic cars and suits siblings who will share.
2 that fit · about $19.48 – $24.78
M&D Wooden Cars Vehicle Setabout $24.78 · amazon.com
M&D Wooden Town Vehiclesabout $19.48 · amazon.com

Drawing and play dough
A magnetic drawing board has no mess or paper, and Play-Doh is for hands on play at the table.
2 that fit · about $7.99 – $12.99
SGILE Magnetic Drawing Boardabout $12.99 · amazon.com
Play-Doh 10 Pack of Modeling Compoundabout $7.99 · amazon.com

Music and headphones
Sound makers and listening gear. A xylophone teaches rhythm, and kid sized headphones limit volume so ears are protected.
2 that fit · about $11.70 – $26.39
Melissa & Doug Caterpillar Wooden Xylophoneabout $11.70 · amazon.com
Belkin SoundForm Mini Kids Headphonesabout $26.39 · amazon.com

Water play
Reusable water mat play. Good for travel and car rides because there is no paint to clean up.
One that fits · about $8.99
Melissa & Doug On the Go Water WOW! Under the Seaabout $8.99 · amazon.com

Ride-ons
A balance bike builds balance without pedals and a rocking horse suits younger toddlers indoors.
2 that fit · about $29.97 – $30.99
Little Tikes Rocking Horseabout $29.97 · amazon.com
SEREED Baby Balance Bikeabout $30.99 · amazon.com